Pile says: Post the oldest (as in the date it was downloaded) MP3 on your computer. An easy way to do this is to sort by “Date Modified” in iTunes. Mine is: Live - I Alone
Mine is Led Zeppelin- Dyer Maker. Downloaded 11/2/97. (update — found an older one — U2’s One, 10/8/97).
Ahhh, mine is ‘Till Tuesday’s “Voices Carry.” In all fairness, my entire iTunes library was deleted and I stole all of the ex’s music. This was first on the list because of the apostrophe. And yes, he did pay money to download this song. It is also listed as my fave song in my 2nd grade yearbook. Sweeeet.